A Marketer’s Guide to managing Martech Innovation and Disruption

Chasefive Management

The Essential Checklist for Avoiding Costly Martech Pitfalls and Prepare for Emerging Tech

Business leaders and marketers know that the current pace of innovation in the Martech sector is unprecedented. The latest Martech Marketing Technology Landscape Supergraphic highlights over ten thousand products spanning over twenty marketing categories. Remarkably, over two thousand new marketing software products, many powered by artificial intelligence (AI), were added in just the second half of 2023 alone.

The drive towards adopting new martech solutions is emphasised by significant financial investment; data from industry analysts reveal a global increase in marketing tech spending. According to a Forrester report, a multi-year martech boom is expected, with global spending projected to rise from $131 billion in 2023 to over $215 billion annually by 2027.

With such a pace of development in marketing software, navigating the complexities of technical, operational, and regulatory compliance can be overwhelming. The risks of misalignment between the intended purpose of marketing technology and its actual use can result in significant costs for organisations of all sizes.

This guide offers a practical checklist to help you avoid issues related to suitability and compliance, ensuring your marketing organization remains protected in a constantly changing environment.

Businesses feel urgency to adopt new martech solutions, while customers expect more.

The convergence of data analytics, artificial intelligence (AI), and automation has sparked an acceleration in marketing technology, compelling businesses to swiftly adapt to compete and thrive. As technology evolves, companies recognise the need to stay competitive. Investing in martech allows marketing teams to deploy more advanced strategies, enhance capabilities, and keep pace with industry trends. Martech solutions enable businesses to understand customer behaviour and tailor marketing efforts accordingly. At the same time, consumers demand personalised experiences, seamless interactions, and relevant content, all of which requires martech to execute.

Businesses feel urgency to adopt new martech solutions, while customers expect more.

Marketing technology shelf life getting shorter amid ‘time to value’ uncertainty.

Organisations aiming to maintain a competitive edge in marketing face the dual challenge of extracting maximum value from their martech investments and keeping pace with swift technological advancements.

The challenge marketing and tech budget owners need to address is understanding the time-to-value periods of new technology and the longevity of the current marketing technology stack. Sectors like artificial intelligence (AI) are driving rapid progress in marketing technology, with AI startups leading the way with quick, innovative solutions that promise short time-to-value (TTV) periods.

Cost of inaction in martech adoption.

In a highly competitive marketing landscape, the speed of technological innovation means budget owners recognise the potential costs of inaction and loss of competitiveness as significant concerns.

Achieving value from martech requires balancing swift deployment with the assurance of substantial returns on investment.

Marketing decision-makers are squeezed between a push for quick results and the risk that hesitation to adopt new martech solutions can result in missed opportunities, such as revenue loss, decreased customer engagement, and eroding brand relevance. Inactivity undermines a brand's competitive edge, impacting market share and customer loyalty.

Chasefive Martech Evaluation Checklist: Choosing the Right Software for Your Marketing Organisation.

With the number of options available in the market, each promising to revolutionise your marketing efforts, selecting the perfect fit can feel overwhelming. However, making an informed choice is crucial to effectively harness the power of martech, driving growth and delivering exceptional customer experiences.

The Chasefive "Martech Evaluation Checklist" guides you through the process of selecting a martech solution that aligns with your organisational goals. This checklist helps identify must-have features and integration capabilities. It involves four stages: assessing business needs, conducting research, selecting vendors, and making an informed decision for future success.

1. Needs Assessment & Feasibility Stage

The journey to selecting the ideal martech solution begins with a thorough Needs Assessment & Feasibility stage. At this early stage, it’s important to clearly define your marketing objectives and ascertain how a new solution can support these goals, whether by enhancing customer engagement, boosting lead generation, or improving personalisation efforts.

This step requires a deep dive into your company’s specific needs, evaluating how the desired functionalities will impact the marketing team and other functions such as sales and customer service operations.

A critical assessment of how each potential tool aligns with your strategic objectives is essential, focusing on its ability to enhance customer experience, improve operational efficiency, and drive revenue growth, starting from defining your marketing needs.

Key steps in the Needs Assessment & Feasibility Stage are:

Defining Marketing Needs: When choosing a marketing technology solution, clarify your objectives for the new tool. Consider functionality, impact on other departments, and ability to enhance customer experience, boost operational efficiency, and contribute to revenue growth. Choose a solution that aligns with your business objectives to achieve marketing goals effectively.

Evaluate current marketing systems: Evaluate your current marketing systems by assessing your existing marketing technology tools. Understand their functionalities, strengths, and limitations. For instance, evaluate whether your current solution supports your objective.
Conduct feasibility check: Establish your budget for new marketing software. Ensure your company has necessary resources (e.g., IT support, training capacity) for effective implementation and management.

2. Research Stage

The Research Stage of selecting a martech solution involves a detailed examination of potential vendors and their offerings. This involves identifying and shortlisting vendors based on features, pricing, scalability, and industry reputation. This stage is vital for narrowing down choices to solutions that offer the right tools, support, and potential for growth alongside your business.

Key steps in the Research Stage are:

Identify vendors: Research and shortlist potential martech vendors based on features, pricing, scalability, and industry reputation.

Understand the martech solution: Review vendor technical information, case studies, and customer reviews to understand each solutions capabilities and potential fit for your needs. Specifically looking at:

Features and functionality: Deep dive into the features and functionalities offered by the martech solution. Does it address your specific needs and provide the capabilities you require?
Integrations: Consider how well the solution integrates with your existing marketing technology stack and other essential business systems (e.g., CRM, CMS). Seamless integration is crucial for a cohesive workflow. Evaluate how well the martech solution integrates with existing tools and systems, including CRM, data analytics platforms, and other marketing software.
Scalability and growth potential: Can the martech solution scale with your business growth? Ensure it can handle increasing data volumes and evolving marketing needs. Ensure the solution can scale with your business and adapt to changing marketing strategies and technologies.
Customisation: Does the solution offer customization options to adapt to your specific workflows and processes?
Security and compliance: Evaluate the data security measures offered by the martech solution. Ensure it complies with relevant data privacy regulations (e.g., GDPR, CCPA) based on your location and target market.

Examine the user experience (UX). Assess the usability of the solution for everyday users, not just IT professionals. A good UX can significantly impact adoption rates and productivity. Consider the learning curve and whether the vendor offers training and support.

In the research stage develop a list of key criteria to evaluate each software solution, including all the points listed above.

3. Selection stage

The selection stage of the marketing technology evaluation process goes beyond just comparing features; it involves a deep dive into how each option can serve your unique business needs and enhance your team's efficiency. This step involves engaging with vendors and reviewing their platforms through demos and free trials, rigorously comparing their offerings, and evaluating each vendor's reputation and support system.

Key steps in the Selection Stage are:

Request demos and free trials: Schedule demos with shortlisted vendors to get a hands-on experience with the software. Utilize any free trial periods offered to further assess usability and functionality.

Compare and contrast: Compare shortlisted software based on your selection criteria, demo experiences, and pricing plans.

Evaluate vendor reputation and support: Research the vendor’s track record, customer service reputation, and the robustness of their support and training offerings. Consider the vendor’s stability and long-term viability to ensure they will be a reliable partner.

4. Decision stage

Selecting the right marketing software for your organisation culminates in the decision stage, where careful negotiation and strategic assessments become paramount. At this point, it's essential to not only finalise the terms with your chosen vendor but also to secure the necessary internal approvals.

This stage involves a delicate balance of negotiating contract terms, pricing, and implementation specifics while also conducting a thorough risk versus reward assessment to ensure the chosen solution aligns with your company's long-term goals and scalability needs.

Navigating this final phase paves the way for a successful technology adoption that not only meets your current requirements but also supports your future growth.

Key steps in the Decision Stage are:

· Negotiate contract: Once you've chosen the preferred vendor, negotiate contract terms, pricing, and implementation details.

· Obtain approval: Secure internal approvals from relevant stakeholders before finalizing the purchase.

· Risk vs. reward assessment. Consider the trade-offs between the potential benefits (reward) and the risks associated with the solution. Evaluate factors such as implementation complexity, ongoing maintenance, and scalability.

Charting a path to Martech success

Whether you are just beginning to explore the possibilities of adopting new marketing technology solutions or upgrading your existing martech stack, the journey is strategic and demands careful consideration at every turn. From clearly defining your marketing needs and assessing the feasibility of new solutions to conducting thorough research on potential vendors and making an informed decision, each step is crucial in selecting a martech solution that aligns with your business objectives.

Remember, the goal is not just to adopt the latest technology but to choose tools that genuinely enhance your marketing capabilities, foster better customer relationships, and drive your business towards sustained growth.

As you navigate this process, keep your strategic goals at the forefront, ensuring that every decision contributes to the broader vision of your company's success in the ever-evolving digital landscape.

Join the FAPI Marketing Framework™ Academy to learn more about marketing team resource planning and team building.

< Older Post

Newer Post >

Understanding the Marketing KPI Divide: Why Production-Level Metrics Don’t Translate for Business Leaders

By Chasefive Management • October 30, 2025

The modern marketing landscape is rich with data. Teams can track campaign clicks, bounce rates, and email opens with precision; yet business leaders still question whether marketing truly drives growth. This disconnect often stems from a gap between production-level KPIs, granular measures used by marketing teams, and business leadership metrics, which focus on strategy, commercial outcomes, and long-term impact. The Leadership Challenge: Relevancy in Marketing KPIs Problems arise when senior leadership misinterprets or undervalues marketing KPIs . Executives often want to see how marketing contributes to strategic goals, but when presented with overly granular metrics, they disengage. Misalignment of Metric Relevance Leadership Focus: The C-suite prioritizes impact metrics such as customer lifetime value, market share growth, or marketing ROI. Marketer Focus: Teams look at tactical measures like CPC, bounce rates, and engagement. The Result: When operational data is given to executives expecting strategic insight, clarity is lost. CPC means little to a CFO concerned with revenue growth. Lack of Trust and Strategic Disconnect Mistrust at the Top: Studies show that nearly 80% of CEOs lack trust in their marketing departments. Much of this distrust comes from poor alignment in metrics. Structural Failures: If strategic goals are not translated into meaningful KPIs, marketing execution becomes scattered. Resource Misallocation: Marketers waste an average of 26% of budgets on ineffective channels when metrics fail to reflect business priorities. The FAPI Marketing Framework stresses tailored reporting, ensuring that each stakeholder, whether CEO, manager, or executive, receives metrics aligned with their role and level of decision-making. Management vs. Production Metrics: A Dual-Lane View To clarify this divide, the FAPI Framework illustrates how management-level metrics differ from production-level metrics and why both are essential.

How to make creativity operational within a performance-driven marketing framework

By Chasefive Management • October 19, 2025

In modern marketing, creativity and performance often seem at odds — one thrives on freedom, the other demands structure. Yet within the FAPI Marketing Framework , these two forces are intentionally designed to coexist. The Plan Master — the central leadership role in FAPI — is responsible for integrating creativity and innovation within a structured, data-driven system. This means ensuring that imaginative thinking is encouraged, but also anchored to commercial and strategic outcomes. In practice, the Production Executives (the creative and technical professionals who execute campaigns) must receive a clear and structured creative brief that defines the strategic intent, boundaries, and success metrics for their work. In FAPI terms, creativity doesn’t operate in chaos — it flourishes within a defined frame.

From Reporting to Prescriptive Analysis: Climbing the Marketing Intelligence Ladder

By Chasefive Management • October 3, 2025

Modern marketing teams sit on a mountain of data, yet turning that data into meaningful decisions remains a challenge. The FAPI Marketing Framework™ offers a clear path: move step by step from operational reporting to strategic prescriptive insights. The diagram below illustrates this progression, showing how marketing intelligence evolves in both complexity and value . The two axes of marketing intelligence The diagram is built on two dimensions: Vertical axis – Human vs. Automation: At the base, processes like reporting are automated and mechanical. As you climb, the need for human interpretation and judgment grows. Horizontal axis – Marketing Value: On the left, activities deliver limited business value by describing the past. Moving right, value increases as insights guide real-time actions and future strategy. Together, these axes show how marketing analysis matures from descriptive outputs to strategic decision-making tools .

Preparing Marketing Data for Decision Making

By Chasefive Management • September 24, 2025

In modern marketing, data is everywhere. But without structure and purpose, data is just noise. The real value comes when data is prepared in a way that makes it actionable, contextual, and aligned with responsibilities . As part of the Insights Module in the FAPI Marketing Framework , preparing marketing data for decision making ensures that teams move beyond collection and reporting, and instead focus on clarity, consistency, and meaning. Why data preparation matters. ensuring reliability and integrity The primary goal of marketing data preparation (covered in the Data Acquisition component of the Insights Module) is to ensure the marketing team has access to the right data, organized and ready for analysis. This is a critical leadership responsibility. Within the FAPI Marketing Framework, this responsibility falls to the Plan Master, who must establish benchmarks and key performance indicators (KPIs) and clearly explain their purpose before execution begins. Getting this right avoids costly misalignment. When teams rely on inaccurate or poorly defined data, they risk making the wrong decisions and allocating resources inefficiently.

Marketing production hierarchy diagram, synchronising marketing execution through operational stages

By Chasefive Management • September 11, 2025

The FAPI Marketing Framework defines a clear hierarchy of terms, particularly regarding the relationship between the user journey, campaigns, and activities, ensuring a structured approach from strategic planning to tactical execution. This hierarchy is crucial for maintaining alignment between marketing efforts and overarching business strategy. 1. User Journey (Phases) The user journey (also called the user lifecycle) is the end-to-end path a person follows as they discover a product, service, or brand. It’s a foundational concept in the Architecture Module. Each company defines where the journey starts and ends, which affects how activities are built and monitored across the experience. Common phases used are: Awareness (or Reach): Getting the brand noticed. Validation (or Engage): Users validate claims and develop curiosity. Consideration: Users seek detailed information and explanations. Intent (or Engage): Users are motivated to take action. Commitment (or Conversion): Users make a purchase or tangible investment. Activation & Growth (or Nurture): Retain customers, drive repeat business, and increase lifetime 2. Campaigns Campaigns represent coordinated activities centred around a single concept and theme to form an integrated marketing communication. They sit within the user journey phases. In the FAPI Marketing Framework, "primary campaigns" are considered strategic and are defined in the Frame Module, making them mission-critical, non-negotiable, and long-term. Examples include Black Friday or Christmas campaigns for an e-commerce business, which are crucial for a large percentage of revenue. A campaign delivers a message created to communicate with potential customers at each phase of the customer journey. Production teams and agencies do not create these strategic campaigns; they receive campaign briefs from the strategic marketing leadership team . Campaigns are conceived at the strategy level, and a campaign conceived wrongly at this stage cannot be redeemed later.

Marketing Performance Leverage Effect. Modeling Synergy Across Marketing Channels

By Chasefive Management • September 3, 2025

The FAPI Marketing Framework—a comprehensive methodology for strategic marketing deployment—culminates in the Insights Module, which focuses on data-driven decision-making and continuous optimization. A critical concept in this module is the Marketing Leverage Effect , first introduced in the Architecture Module for forecasting campaign outcomes. The Leverage Effect highlights how multiple marketing activities across diverse channels interact and influence one another, producing a collective output greater than the sum of individual efforts. In the Insights Module, understanding the Leverage Effect is essential for accurately interpreting actual campaign performance, especially when assessing correlations between user-journey stages. By analyzing these interactions, organizations move beyond isolated metrics and derive actionable recommendations from a holistic view of how marketing investments work together.