Resolving marketing dissatisfaction: Time for CEOs to take a more proactive role in marketing performance.

Chasefive Management

Anyone fortunate enough to manage a marketing function or be responsible for a marketing budget would confirm the marketing landscape is facing several challenges causing disruption and requiring a new approach to marketing management.


The traditional boundaries between marketing practice and other customer-facing functions have become less clear, and marketing operational complexity is constantly increasing, making it crucial for the businesses to adapt to these new realities.

Amid these dynamic shifts, it's clear from numerous studies and publications that dissatisfaction with marketing efforts is widespread among business leaders. A notable example is a study published by the Harvard Business Review, revealing that 80% of CEOs are not satisfied with the performance of their Chief Marketing Officers (CMOs), citing a lack of trust.

The widespread discontent can be attributed to a multitude of factors. Chief Marketing Officers (CMOs) encounter immense pressure to achieve tangible and measurable results in the evolving marketing landscape. At the same time, business leadership teams face the challenge of effectively integrating marketing into their organizational structure, given the increasingly blurred boundaries between distinct marketing responsibilities in other functional areas.


Exploring the reasons behind businesses' dissatisfaction with marketing.


Frequently cited reasons for the general dissatisfaction with marketing among CEO and business leaders include multiple crucial issues. Among these, a recurrent concern is the lack of quantifiable outcomes, where marketing endeavours struggle to deliver concrete, measurable results demonstrating a clear return on investment.

Misalignment with organizational objectives also ranks high on the list of discontents. Marketing campaigns are frequently said to need to be more closely aligned with broader business goals, leading to frustration and a sense of disconnect.

In addition, inadequate cross-functional collaboration with other business functions often hinders effective marketing planning and execution. Poor interdepartmental integration and a lack of communication can lead to disjointed execution.

Another significant cause of dissatisfaction is the failure of marketing teams to grasp the intricacies and specificity of their respective industries, resulting in messaging and strategies that fall short of resonating with target audiences.

Insufficient ability to adapt to ever-changing market dynamics trends leaves businesses yearning for more agile and responsive marketing efforts that can better address evolving customer preferences and market trends.

Finally, a need for more clarity on scope and competencies especially among production execution teams is a frequently cited reason for lack of efficiency and suboptimal performance.


It's no surprise that the tenure of Chief Marketing Officers is shorter than that of other C-suite roles.


A holistic view of marketing organizational planning.


Successfully integrating business vision and marketing production necessitates the active involvement of the entire organization's leadership and management team throughout the marketing process, from planning to resourcing and execution.

The diagram below, adapted from Jonathan Trevor and Barry Varcoe's alignment test, provides a simple way to evaluate how a marketing plan is aligned with a company's strategy and assess the potential risks and pitfalls.

Strategic marketing alignment diagram. Giovannoni, E. (2023). Modern Marketing Architecture: The Official FAPI Marketing FrameworkTM Guidebook. Chasefive.


The alignment diagram emphasizes two clear keystones of marketing success. Firstly, the organization's tactical marketing plans and business plan must be integrated. Secondly, the marketing resources and capability must correspond with the marketing plan.


An anecdotal early-stage litmus test for business leadership teams to determine whether their business and marketing organizations require better integration is when the company tends to consider individual marketing 'big ideas' as solutions to enhance marketing performance rather than viewing the marketing organizational performance as a whole.

 

Difficulties in aligning business vision with marketing execution.


Many executive teams tend to tackle marketing reactively by responding to immediate needs or ad-hoc opportunities rather than adopting a strategic approach to organizational planning, yet the battle for alignment between business direction and marketing execution is won or lost in the planning stage.

A modern marketing organizational plan needs to be collaborative and coherent, starting with correctly 'encoding' the business vision and objectives in the marketing plans. CEOs and business leadership teams need to take responsibility for leading the process starting with the strategy 'encoding' stage.

The strategy-encoding process stands as a core responsibility of the business leadership team, collaborating closely with the CMO. In the strategy encoding process, the CMO acts as a gatekeeper to identify any gaps or ambiguity in the strategy brief that could pose risks during the execution stage and ensure these are addressed before decoding the strategy into a comprehensive tactical plan.

A classic example of how frequently the process of encoding the strategy is overlooked or misinterpreted is the common practice by businesses of all sizes to dive into marketing production as soon as budgets are approved without first crystallizing the marketing architecture. 



Closing the gap between business strategy and marketing execution.


To effectively translate business strategy into successful tactical marketing activities , a comprehensive end-to-end approach to marketing organizational planning is essential. This process should revolve around key principles that form the foundation for alignment and collaboration. In summary, the keystone requirements can be outlined as follows.


1: Integration.

Integrate all functional leads into the planning process.

It is crucial to involve all key stakeholders in the marketing planning process, including managers from all functional teams, such as sales, product development, customer service, and other relevant departments. Encouraging open communication, resource sharing and responsibility will lead to developing a more cohesive and unified plan.


2: Tactical marketing models.

Adopt a tactical marketing model fit for the business model.

In today's rapidly changing business environment, technology adoption and disruptive business norms have made it difficult to distinguish between different traditional tactical marketing models. Simply relying on standard structures like B2B, B2C, or D2C may not lead to the best alignment between marketing implementation and business goals. The lines between tactical marketing models need to be better defined by identifying how specific target audience behavioural traits and business model characteristics intersect (refer to the FAPI Marketing Framework™ Tactical Marketing Models Matrix).


3: Preparation

Only begin production once the bill of materials is ready.

Starting marketing production without a complete architecture plan and bill of materials can cause significant deviations from the business vision. To mitigate this risk, it's essential to follow a sequential project flow, making sure all execution parameters, such as resource plans, performance indicators, and outcome projections, are clearly defined prior to commencing production.


4: Clarity.

Allocate clear responsibilities, workflows and scope of work.

Poorly defined responsibility allocation during execution can significantly impact production workflows, causing confusion and inefficiencies. All production team members must have a clear understanding of their specific roles and a tactical awareness of the entire marketing plan. Lack of clarity can lead to inconsistent flows resulting in fragmented execution and risking the loss of direction.


5: System thinking.

Interpret insights holistically.

The main aim of marketing data analysis is to predict and control outcomes. However, the complex nature of marketing requires us to understand analytical insights as a whole, focusing on the interrelation of all marketing efforts and understanding correlations rather than breaking marketing activities down into individual isolated parts.


Anyone working in or with marketing would easily recognize real-life scenarios for most of the abovementioned points. The challenge of addressing these issues, even in a small organization, cannot be overstated, and it demands both strong leadership and tactical execution know-how. Yet, this is the expectation for today's modern marketing leaders, who must be astute marketing strategists, competent project managers, and technically savvy specialists.


Placing marketing teams in a position to excel.


A comprehensive marketing planning and organizational framework is a strategic investment. A strong marketing structure not only gives business leadership teams control over the marketing organization but empowers marketing production teams with the necessary resources, direction, and focus to unleash their creativity and innovation, allowing them to concentrate on creating compelling campaigns that truly resonate with the target audience and can yield results, leading to improved outcomes, heightened efficiency, and maximized return on marketing investment (MROI).


Marketing has assumed an increasingly significant role in organizations; however, the workflows and methodologies utilized do not correspond proportionally to the level of responsibility. Marketing lags behind other industries such as manufacturing, engineering, IT, or logistics when it comes to organizational planning. There is no doubt that it is the responsibility of senior leadership teams to address this issue and close the gap between business strategy and marketing execution.


Get in touch to learn more about the FAPI Marketing Framework™ 

By Chasefive Management July 27, 2025
Within the FAPI Marketing Framework, the rationale behind categorizing metrics into Delivery Metrics, Performance Metrics, and Impact Metrics is to ensure a comprehensive and multi-layered evaluation of marketing effectiveness, facilitating strategic decision-making and continuous performance improvement. This categorization, crucial for the Insights Module, helps to make sense of marketing data and effectively evaluate outcomes.
By Chasefive Management July 24, 2025
Based on the FAPI Marketing Framework Official Guidebook, a modern marketing manager or Plan Master requires a diverse and comprehensive skill set to effectively navigate the complexities of contemporary marketing. Their role is central to leading projects, ensuring alignment, and driving results across the entire marketing process. The key skills and competencies of a modern marketing manager or Plan Master are centred on four key areas: Leadership & Management Strategic & Analytical Technical & Operational Interpersonal & Communication 1. Leadership & Management Skills Project Leadership and Oversight: The Marketing Manager leads the implementation of the FAPI Marketing Framework within the organization, overseeing the entire project lifecycle and ensuring all steps are completed efficiently. They provide leadership and coordination throughout the process of translating strategic vision into execution requirements. They are responsible for making key decisions during execution, especially when unexpected situations or adjustments are necessary. Team Building and Empowerment: They are responsible for forming the virtual marketing team, selecting individuals with the necessary skills and expertise, whether internal staff or external contractors. The Marketing Manager must take a holistic view when building the team, understanding the dynamics involved to ensure optimal performance. They act as a coach, supporting and empowering Production Executives by identifying and removing roadblocks and ensuring they have the necessary resources and support. Fostering a positive and collaborative team environment where members feel comfortable expressing themselves is essential. Resource Management and Financial Acumen: They oversee the financial management of the FAPI Framework, ensuring a return on marketing investment performance. This includes assessing resource availability, developing an allocation plan, and continuously monitoring and adjusting financial, human, and technological resources. They must ensure the Production Executive team is appropriately resourced. Quality Control and Efficiency Promotion: The Marketing Manager promotes a quality mindset within the marketing organization, focusing on reducing errors and friction at every step of the Production stage. They use transparent Production practices to allow for retrospective analysis to identify bottlenecks and inefficiencies. The Framework is designed for systematic review and continuous improvement, which the Marketing Manager champions. Process Optimization: They can use techniques like the '5 Whys' to identify root causes of productivity shortfalls and streamline workflows.
By Author: Emiliano Giovannoni July 17, 2025
In the increasingly complex world of marketing operations, deploying the right marketing technology (MarTech) requires more than just selecting the latest tools. It requires a structured approach that aligns with both productivity and performance objectives. The FAPI Marketing Framework™, developed by Chasefive, offers a strategic blueprint for this process through a dual-lane deployment model: the Productivity Lane and the Performance Lane. This two-swimlane schema ensures MarTech implementation is both operationally efficient and strategically impactful. Each lane comprises four progressive stages: Core Logic , Business Processes , Systems , and Outcomes . Let’s take a look at how this view helps businesses structure their MarTech stack for maximum effectiveness. 1. Core Logic. Defining the Foundation Every successful MarTech deployment begins with a clearly defined Core Logic. This stage sets the fundamental principles that guide how tools and processes are structured. In the Productivity Lane , the Core Logic is rooted in the Marketing Operational Structure . This includes clearly defined marketing roles, scopes of work (SOW), and team responsibilities, ensuring everyone understands their role in the execution engine. In the Performance Lane , the Core Logic is defined by the Marketing Strategy Model . This includes your resource allocation rationale and how well these decisions align with broader strategic objectives. It ensures that performance tools serve a purpose beyond execution; they support strategic goals. 2. Business Processes. Structuring Workflows With foundational logic in place, the second stage involves building out Business Processes that serve as the operational spine for the MarTech stack. Productivity Lane processes include clear marketing production workflows , defined roles and rituals, and coordinated resource allocation. These ensure work moves efficiently across teams with clarity and consistency. At the same time, the Performance Lane processes focus on end-to-end data flow and seamless performance data capture, integration, and analysis. This structure enables a holistic view of marketing outcomes and supports evidence-based decision-making. 3. Systems. Selecting the Right Tools Only after the processes are in place should technology tools be evaluated, selected, and integrated. Productivity Lane systems include your management tools , such as collaboration platforms, project management software, and administrative solutions that keep operations running smoothly. Performance Lane systems are your marketing campaign tools . These include platforms for campaign activation, tracking, and optimization, ensuring marketing efforts are tied to measurable business goals. 4. Outcomes. Driving Results Through Structure The final stage of the MarTech schema links tools to their outcomes. The Productivity Lane focuses on driving operational productivity, grounded in marketing structure and workflows, which helps teams deliver more efficiently and consistently. Therefore, the outcomes measured in the Productivity Lane are linked to production metrics, examining efficiency and execution against operational targets. The Performance Lane focuses on strategic and commercial performance, as it is tied to the marketing model and data flow, enabling the achievement of customer-specific outcomes aligned with commercial objectives. The outcomes measured in the Performance Lane are linked to commercial targets. The Chasefive MarTech Deployment Schema is designed to ensure that every technology decision in marketing is made in context, not in isolation. It brings structure and strategic alignment to MarTech implementation by dividing the deployment process into two interconnected project lanes. At its core, this schema is about relevance—ensuring each tool, process, and integration directly supports either operational efficiency or commercial outcomes. Rather than selecting technology based on feature sets, vendor hype, or isolated departmental needs, the FAPI Marketing Framework™ model anchors decisions in a broader strategic and operational logic.
By Author: Emiliano Giovannoni July 7, 2025
A long-standing, well-known recipe for marketing success is driven by a simple equation: more output equals more results. This involves gaining visibility through increased volume and pacing by activating more channels, campaigns, posts, articles, and so on to secure greater exposure. The dominant strategy of ' volume marketing ' relies on increasing output to enhance performance. Marketers would focus on ramping up production and releasing campaigns at increasingly rapid speeds to cut through the noise, and for many, this approach has proven effective. The future of volume marketing and zero marginal cost scenario in marketing production In the age of AI, this once-reliable strategy is experiencing diminishing returns. As more output is generated, it becomes increasingly difficult for any single message to stand out, and the content becomes less valuable to users. The process of commoditization of marketing production began with the offshoring of marketing production services, where a significant portion of marketing tasks was shifted to low-cost economies. Artificial intelligence has compounded this effect, accelerating the shift toward a zero marginal cost scenario in marketing production. The AI productivity boost to marketing output means we are approaching a world saturated with content, and simply doing more is no longer enough. EEAT and the shift from volume to value To address the challenge of distinguishing content in an environment where virtually unlimited content can be produced at a fraction of the cost, Google introduced the E-E-A-T guidelines (E-E-A-T, stands for Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness). These guidelines are used to evaluate the quality of newly published web pages and their content, recognizing and rewarding material that is original, authoritative, and trustworthy.
By Chasefive Management June 15, 2025
In today's fast-paced business environment, marketing can't afford to operate in a silo. When sales, product development, and marketing teams aren't on the same page, the result is often a disjointed customer experience and wasted effort. But how can organisations bridge these departmental divides? The FAPI Marketing Framework offers a powerful solution, creating a structure that doesn't just manage tasks, but actively cultivates collaboration. The framework's strength lies in its ability to foster a unified, cohesive approach to all marketing efforts. Let's explore the key mechanisms it uses to break down silos and get everyone pulling in the same direction. Building a Unified Front with Cross-Functional Teamwork At its core, the FAPI Framework is built on the principle of inclusion. It explicitly champions the creation of cross-functional teams, ensuring that key stakeholders from across the organisation are involved in the marketing process from the outset. This isn't just about inviting other departments to a meeting; it's about embedding them into the process. Through structured "project events," representatives from various departments actively participate and contribute. This inclusive approach dismantles the "us vs. them" mentality and fosters a powerful, shared sense of ownership and accountability for the success of marketing initiatives. When everyone has a hand in building the plan, everyone is invested in its success. Clarity Through Structure: Defined Roles for Seamless Coordination Collaboration can be chaotic without clear leadership and structure. FAPI addresses this by establishing well-defined roles that facilitate, rather than hinder, teamwork. Two roles are particularly critical for ensuring smooth marketing coordination : The Plan Master: This individual is the central hub for collaboration. The Plan Master is responsible for assembling the dedicated project team, enabling effective communication between all members, and coordinating the various activities required to achieve the marketing objectives. They act as the conductor, ensuring all parts of the orchestra are playing in harmony. Functional Leads: These individuals are the experts from different functional areas (like digital, content, or product marketing). They provide essential cross-functional support by coordinating resources and lending their expertise to the plan. Functional Leads collaborate directly with the Plan Master to develop specific modules of the strategy, ensuring that every component is both effective on its own and perfectly aligned with the broader plan. The Cornerstone: Promoting Communication and Understanding Finally, the FAPI Framework promotes the single most important ingredient for successful collaboration: communication. By creating a structured environment where different departments are required to interact, the framework naturally enhances communication and deepens mutual understanding. This constant dialogue minimises the risk of misalignment between marketing activities and overarching business objectives. It ensures that the creative campaign designed by the marketing team supports the sales team's targets and reflects the latest product updates from the development team. The result is a cohesive strategy where all efforts are synchronised and contribute directly to the organisation's most important goals. In short, the FAPI Framework is more than just a tool for planning—it's a blueprint for building a collaborative culture that drives powerful, unified results.
By Chasefive Management May 31, 2025
In the world of marketing, accountability can sometimes feel like a moving target. But what if there was a system that made progress and responsibility visible at every turn? The FAPI Marketing Framework does just that, and one of its key mechanisms is the use of Defined Deliverables at each stage. The FAPI Framework is designed to highlight accountability in marketing , ensuring efforts align with overall business objectives. While it establishes clear roles and responsibilities and emphasizes performance measurement, cross-functional collaboration, continuous improvement, and budgetary accountability, the structure of its deliverables is a powerful tool for transparency. The Framework is structured with clear deliverables at each stage, which makes progress and accountability visible. Think of these deliverables as essential milestones, showing exactly what should be completed at each phase of the project and who is responsible for delivering it. This ensures that responsibilities are met throughout the project stages. Here's a look at the specific deliverables associated with each module in the FAPI Framework, as outlined in the source: For the Frame Module, the deliverable is the Strategy Brief. This brief outlines the business vision and strategic goals, setting the foundation for the entire project. Its completion signifies that the initial strategic direction has been defined and agreed upon. Moving to the Architecture Module, the deliverable is the Marketing Playbook. This is a detailed operational document designed for execution, translating the strategy into concrete plans and processes. Having this document ready demonstrates that the operational blueprint is complete. In the Production Module, the deliverable is the activities themselves. This means the tangible output of the marketing work – whether it's creative assets, campaign launches, content creation, etc. – serves as the deliverable. This directly shows that the execution phase is underway and producing results. Finally, for the Insights Module, the output consists of reports and recommended actions. This deliverable shows the results of performance analysis and provides data-driven suggestions for next steps.  These defined deliverables act as checkpoints, ensuring that progress is visible and that stakeholders are held accountable for their contributions at each phase of the project. By clearly outlining what needs to be produced at every step, the FAPI Framework builds transparency and ensures that marketing efforts contribute effectively to the organization's overall success. Don't let accountability be an afterthought! Enroll in the FAPI Marketing Framework Certification Course today and gain the skills to lead effective, transparent, and accountable marketing initiatives that deliver measurable results.
More posts